Dying and Rising Gods New

The present book is a contribution to the study of the origins and development of the dying and rising god mythologem in the second millennium BCE. As outlined in the Introduction, since the publication of James G. Frazer’s research towards the end of the nineteenth century, the scholarship has dealt extensively and continuously with the influential mythologem of the dying and rising god.  The study follows this mythologem in its narrow definition (as adapted twenty years ago, particularly by Tryggve N.D. Mettinger), aiming to fill a lacuna in previous studies on this topic. Its objective is to trace the mythologem’s origins and its dissemination route amongst the ancient Near Eastern cultures. To this end, the study examines the earliest texts attesting to the mythologem in question, all from West Asia of the second millennium BCE, including Mesopotamia, Mari, Ugarit and another Northwest Semitic culture reflected in a Hittite text. As it turns out, along with the few early texts that describe the return from the netherworld of a god who had been killed, many others attest to a different sort of a mythologem; namely, the death of a god without his revival. The scholarship of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries led many scholars through the present day to consider this variant as a part of the complex mythologem of a god dying and being resurrected. However, the extant evidence presented in this study demonstrates that the distribution of the revival concept in its early years was in fact limited. Moreover, influenced by early scholarship, many scholars regard the Mesopotamian god Dumuzi as the most dominant among the gods who had died and risen from the dead. As such, it is commonly argued that Dumuzi’s qualities influenced the depiction of other gods, like Baal and later Adonis. However, the extant evidence discussed in this study disproves this assumption. While the concept of a rising god is hardly present in the numerous unearthed Mesopotamian texts, the sparse evidence originating in Levantine cultures seems to indicate an ongoing familiarity with the mythologem of the dying and rising god, whose protagonist in the second millennium BCE appears to be Baal the Storm God.

Preface  

Introduction

A. Aims and Context

B. Findings  

C. Scope  

D. Some Preliminary Notes

Chapter 1. The Evolution of Research on the Dying and Rising God in Mesopotamian Texts

A. The Early Era of Research: Late Antiquity Writings and the Decipherment of Ištar’s Descent  

B. Research in the 1950s: After Deciphering Most of Inana’s Descent

C. Research from the 1960s Onwards: After Deciphering the Last Lines of Inana’s Descent  

D. Inana’s Descent and Related Compositions: A Discussion  

1. Dumuzi and Geštinana  

2. The Death of Dumuzi

3. Ištar’s Descent

4. Inana’s Descent

E. Conclusions  

Chapter 2. The Dying and Rising God in Mari Texts

A. Tablet A.1146: The Death and Return of Dumuzi  

B. Tablet A.4540: The Burial of Dumuzi  

C. Tablet MARI 5, 1987.14: The Return of Dumuzi

D. Discussion and Conclusions

Chapter 3. The Dying and Rising God in Ugaritic Texts

A. A Brief Overview of The Baal Cycle

1. The Literary Boundaries of the Baal vs. Yamm Conflict  

2. The Plotline of the Baal vs. Yamm Conflict

3. The Relations between the Gods in the Baal vs. Yamm Conflict  

4. The Literary Design of the Characters in the Baal vs. Yamm Conflict  

5. The Authorship of the Baal vs. Yamm Conflict

B. A Summary of the Dying God Mythologem  

C. Baal as a Dying and Rising God

1. Baal’s Death (KTU 1.5 V – 1.6 I 31; 1.6 II 13–23; 1.19 I; 1.12)

2. Baal’s Revival (KTU 1.6 III–IV; 1.17 VI)

3. Conclusions 

D. Mot as a Dying and Rising God  

1. Mot’s Death (KTU 1.6 II 30–35; IV 11–19; 1.23 8–11)  

2. Mot’s Reappearance (KTU 1.6 II 35–37; V 7–11)  

E. Conclusions

Chapter 4. The Dying and Rising God in a Text of Northwest Semitic Origin

A. The Myth of Elkunirša, Ašertu, and the Storm God (CTH 342.1)  

B. Discussion and Conclusions

Chapter 5. The Dying and Rising God in the Post-Ugaritic Levant

A. Ritualistic Aspects of the Dying and Rising God Mythologem in Later Periods

B. Literary Aspects of the Dying and Rising God Mythologem in Later Periods

Chapter 6. Sources Related to the Storm God’s Descent to the Netherworld without a Subsequent Ascent

A. Iškur And Enlil (Ni 12501)

B. The Song of Release (CTH 789)

C. Zechariah 12:10–11  

D. Conclusions  

Chapter 7. Summary and Conclusions

A. Early Occurrences of the Dying and Rising God Mythologem in the Ancient Near East

B. The Origin and Development of the Dying and Rising God Mythologem in West Asia  

C. Epilogue

Bibliography

Indices